Nov 1, 2025 | Financial Planning

Retiring Before 65 – What About Health Insurance?

As we continue this series on health insurance, we are moving on from our Medicare discussion last month to considering what to do about health insurance for those who retire prior to age 65. While the health insurance decision is straightforward for those who have reached age 65, it is much more difficult for those who haven’t.

In fact, many individuals don’t even consider retirement prior to age 65 specifically because they are concerned about how to maintain health insurance until they qualify for Medicare.

In this blog post, we will discuss the options available for individuals who would like to retire prior to age 65 but are concerned about their health insurance options.

To start, we’ll walk through the coverage options that are available, which questions to ask when determining the best coverage for you, and finally, how to pay for coverage including how to qualify for tax credits that can reduce your out-of-pocket premiums.

Coverage Options – Where to Start?

For most individuals considering early retirement, one of the first health insurance options to consider is continuing coverage from their employer.

COBRA Coverage:

COBRA, or the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act, is a federal law that requires group health plans to provide temporary continuation of group health coverage to qualifying individuals.

COBRA applies to group health plans maintained by private-sector employers with 20 or more employees. The extended coverage may be offered to employees, their spouses, former spouses, and dependent children when coverage has been lost due to certain qualifying events.

For a covered employee, these qualifying events include termination of their employment (for any reason other than gross misconduct) or a reduction in the number of hours they work.

Thus, an individual who retires completely or cuts back their hours and no longer qualifies for the employer’s group health plan would qualify for COBRA coverage.

If an individual qualifies for COBRA coverage, they typically have 60 days to choose whether or not they want to elect continuation coverage.

Group health coverage through COBRA is typically more expensive than group health coverage for active employees. The reason is that employers generally cover a portion of the health insurance premiums for active employees, but they are not required to cover any of the premiums for those participating through COBRA. So, individuals who leave employment and elect COBRA should expect to see a significant increase in their health insurance premiums.

In addition to possibly having to pay 100% of the premium cost out to their own pocket, those covered under COBRA may be charged an additional 2% over and above the cost of the premiums to cover administrative costs.

COBRA is not intended to be a long-term solution, but it does provide an option to continue coverage for a period of time shortly after leaving employment.

The maximum length of COBRA coverage varies depending on the specific qualifying event. Those who are eligible for COBRA as a result of retiring or reducing their hours are eligible for up to 18 months of coverage. The following table shows the maximum duration of COBRA depending on the qualifying event.

COBRA graph qualifying event duration of coverage

Individuals who choose to retire or lose their job in the middle of a year will often choose to enroll in COBRA for at least the remainder of the year for a couple reasons.

First, it is often easier to stay with a familiar plan rather than researching and selecting a new plan at a time when they are already making other major decisions.

Second, if they have already used part of their deductible during the year, keeping the same plan often is a better decision than switching to a new plan where their deductible would be reset.

While COBRA is a simple choice for individuals needing short-term coverage, those who are retiring more than 18 months before reaching age 65 or who want to qualify for premium tax credits should consider additional options to find a long-term solution.

Key Takeaway:

For individuals who have retired or lost their job, COBRA can provide a short-term option for health insurance – especially for those who have already used part of their deductible and don’t want to change plans mid-year.

Health Insurance Marketplace:

The Health Insurance Marketplace was created by the Affordable Care Act which is frequently referred to as Obamacare.

The Health Insurance Marketplace provides a place for individuals who are not covered by a workplace plan or Medicare to purchase health insurance. Most states utilize the Healthcare.gov website to run their marketplace exchange; however there a few states that run their own exchanges.

Those who decide not to elect COBRA coverage or are nearing the end of their COBRA eligibility can consider purchasing a health insurance plan through the Health Insurance Marketplace.

When reviewing Marketplace plans, there are four categories (or “metal levels”) of plans. These are Bronze, Silver, Gold, and Platinum. The differences between the categories are based on the plan’s share versus the individual’s share of costs for covered services.

In general, as the metal levels increase, the plan’s share of costs for covered services increases and the individual’s share decreases as shown in the chart below from the healthcare.gov website.

Marketplace four metal level categories graph

Source: https://www.healthcare.gov/choose-a-plan/plans-categories/

In addition to the four categories, the network types can vary from one Marketplace plan to another as explained below:

  • Exclusive Provider Organization (EPO): With an EPO plan, services are generally only covered for doctors, specialists, or hospitals that are included in the plan’s network (except in an emergency).
  • Health Maintenance Organization (HMO): With an HMO plan, coverage is typically limited to doctors who are connected with the HMO network. Out-of-network care is not typically covered unless in an emergency. Given the restrictive nature of the HMO network, HMO plans may require you to live or work in its service area to be eligible for coverage.
  • Point of Service (POS): With a POS plan, care costs less when using in-network medical care. In order to see a specialist, a POS plan will require a referral from the primary care provider.
  • Preferred Provider Organization (PPO): With a PPO plan, individuals can receive care from both in-network and out-of-network providers; however care from out-of-network providers typically comes with an added cost.

As can be expected with the different types of plans and available networks, the cost associated with plans purchased through the Marketplace will vary. The costs associated with the plans generally include monthly premiums, deductibles, coinsurance payments, and maximum out of pocket limits.

Even though plans can differ from one another in many ways, there are standard coverages that every plan sold through the Marketplace must provide. These standard coverages include coverage for the following essential health benefits:

  • Ambulatory patient services (outpatient care you get without being admitted to a hospital)
  • Emergency services
  • Hospitalization (like surgery and overnight stays)
  • Pregnancy, maternity, and newborn care (both before and after birth)
  • Mental health and substance use disorder services, including behavioral health treatment (this includes counseling and psychotherapy)
  • Prescription drugs
  • Rehabilitative and habilitative services and devices (services and devices to help people with injuries, disabilities, or chronic conditions gain or recover mental and physical skills)
  • Laboratory services
  • Preventive and wellness services and chronic disease management
  • Pediatric services, including oral and vision care (but adult dental and vision coverage aren’t essential health benefits)

In addition to these essential health benefits, plans may offer additional benefits including dental coverage, vision coverage, and other programs for specific needs like weight management, back pain, diabetes, etc.

Because each plan offered through the Marketplace can vary, it is important to consider each individual’s circumstances to determine what benefits are most important.

One common question is whether Marketplace plans cover pre-existing conditions. With the passage of the Affordable Care Act, all Marketplace plans are required to provide essential health benefits even for conditions that were present prior to enrolling in the plan.

Additional common questions for an individual to consider when looking for a plan that fits their needs include:

  1. Are preferred doctors and specialists included in the plan’s network?
  2. Does the plan provide coverage for regular prescription medications?
  3. How much flexibility is available to receive care from providers outside the network?
  4. Is the plan compatible with a Health Savings Account (HSA)?
  5. Are lower monthly premiums worth the potential for higher deductibles and out-of-pocket costs, or is it preferable to pay higher premiums for reduced out-of-pocket exposure?
  6. What coinsurance and copayment responsibilities will apply under the plan?

Key Takeaway:

There are many options when choosing a plan through the Health Insurance Marketplace. Because of this, it is important to compare multiple plans to find the one that best fits your specific needs.

While reviewing the coverage provided by various plans is key, another important aspect of purchasing health insurance is understanding the cost and how to pay for coverage.

How To Pay for Health Insurance:

For many individuals, the idea of paying for health insurance coverage on their own is something they don’t even consider.

Frequently, we discuss with individuals who have significant assets and more than enough income to cover the costs of health insurance who simply haven’t considered retirement prior to age 65 because they assume there is no way to pay for health insurance apart from their employer or Medicare.

While there are options to make health insurance more affordable, it is important to first consider that health insurance can be purchased and paid for directly by an individual who chooses to retire early. While it is expensive, it is no different than any other cost that can be included in the financial plan and budget.

For example, assume a husband and wife who are both 61 years old have $2,000,000 in retirement assets and have determined they have sufficient assets to retire – apart from their concern about health insurance costs.

If we assume that they will need to purchase a Marketplace plan for 4 years at a cost of $25,000 per year, they could simply set aside $100,000 today to cover their insurance premiums for the next four years. Then they can reassess their ability to retire based on the remaining $1,900,000 in retirement assets.

When considering a similar analysis, most families will find that the retirement decision will not hinge on the cost of paying health insurance premiums for few short years. If paying health insurance premiums for a few years brings the entire retirement decision into question, the feasibility of retirement is likely debatable to start with.

While paying for health insurance directly is a viable option for some individuals, it still makes sense to consider the options available to make the cost of health insurance more affordable.

Availability of Premium Tax Credits:

Given the high cost of health insurance, the government has implemented a tax credit that is intended to help reduce the cost of health insurance for those who qualify. These premium tax credits are income-based credits designed for taxpayers with moderate to low incomes. Those who claim premium tax credits are required to file IRS Form 8962 with their tax return each year.

In general, the concept of premium tax credits is that individuals should be responsible for using a certain percentage of their income for health insurance; however if the insurance exceeds that acceptable percentage, the premium tax credits kick in to cover the difference.

Many individuals may assume they don’t qualify given the credit is based on income; however, individuals looking at early retirement will typically experience a significant drop in income once they leave employment. Additionally, they can often plan strategically to manage their income in the early years of retirement to qualify for credits.

To start, individuals eligible for premium tax credits must meet all of the following requirements:

  1. Have household income that meets certain requirements (explained below).
  2. Not file a married filing separately tax return (unless a special exception applies).
  3. Not be claimed as a dependent by another person; and
  4. The individual or a family member must:
    • Be enrolled in coverage through a Marketplace plan.
    • Be unable to get affordable coverage through an employer-sponsored plan that provides minimum value.
    • Be ineligible for coverage through a government program like Medicaid, Medicare, CHIP or TRICARE.
    • Pay the share of premiums not covered by the advance credit payments.

Given one of the requirements to receive premium tax credits is being enrolled in a Marketplace plan, eligibility for premium tax credits is one reason an individual may choose to decline COBRA coverage after terminating employment.

How Premium Tax Credits Are Calculated:

To meet the income eligibility requirements for premium tax credits, an individual’s income (defined as modified adjusted gross income from their tax return) must be at least 100 percent but no more than 400 percent of the federal poverty line.

For tax years 2021 through 2025, Congress temporarily expanded the eligibility for premium tax credits by allowing individuals with a household income above 400 percent of the federal poverty line to qualify.

This provision is set to expire after 2025, which would again remove the eligibility for premium tax credits for those with income over 400 percent of the federal poverty line (barring any new legislative action by Congress).

NOTE – As this blog post is being published, an extension of the expanded eligibility is currently the primary sticking point between Democrats and Republicans as they negotiate a bill to fund and reopen the federal government.

The federal poverty line is updated annually and depends on family size which includes the taxpayer, their spouse if filing jointly, and dependents.

Additionally, there are three separate federal poverty lines (due to different costs of living). One for the lower 48 states including the District of Columbia, one for Alaska, and one for Hawaii.

2025 Federal Poverty Levels graph

Since premium tax credits are available for individuals with income up to 400% of the federal poverty line (and even higher in some cases during 2025), a married couple living in North Dakota with modified adjusted gross income of up to $81,760 (i.e. $20,440 x 400%) can qualify. Thus, planning strategies (discussed later) that minimize taxable income during years when the family is on a Marketplace plan can be very valuable.

When calculating the amount of premium tax credits an individual can receive, their income as a percentage of the federal poverty line determines the percentage of their income that they are responsible for contributing toward their health insurance premiums (i.e. applicable figure). The applicable percentages can be determined by reviewing the applicable figure table in the IRS instructions for Form 8962.

The second factor that impacts the level of premium tax credits are the premiums for the Second Lowest Cost Silver Plan (SLCSP) in the area where the individual lives.

To avoid incentivizing individuals to go out and purchase an extremely expensive plan just because the government will pay for it, premium tax credits are limited based on the premiums of the SLCSP available regardless of which plan the individual chooses.

Therefore, even if the individual enrolls in a plan and pays a premium that exceeds that of the SLCSP, their premium tax credits will be limited based on the premiums for the SLCSP.

To get an estimate of what the premiums are for the Second Lowest Cost Silver Plan in specific areas, individuals can use the HealthCare.gov SLCSP estimator tool.

To show the potential benefit of premium tax credits and how they are calculated consider the following example:

John and Jill are a married couple filing a joint return. They live in North Dakota and are planning to retire in 2025 at age 61. They will purchase health insurance through the Marketplace and will continue to do so until they can enroll in Medicare.

John and Jill’s eligibility for premium tax credits in 2025 will be dependent on the federal poverty line for the 48 contiguous states with a family size of two which is equal to $20,440.

John and Jill expect to have income of $60,000 in 2025, so they are projected to be at 293 percent of the federal poverty line. John and Jill will then use this percentage to determine the amount of income they are required to contribute toward their premiums.

At 293 percent, their applicable figure would be 0.0572 which means they will be expected to contribute 5.72% of their income toward their health insurance premiums.

Multiplying this percentage by their household income of $60,000 shows that John and Jill are expected to contribute $3,432 towards their health insurance premiums. Any difference between this amount and the cost of the Second Lowest Cost Silver Plan in their area would be covered by a premium tax credit.

If we assume the premiums for the SLCSP are $21,000 for their area in 2025, they would be eligible to receive a PTC of $17,568 ($21,000 – $3,432).

Premium tax credit calculation example

As this example shows, premium tax credits can be substantial and can offset a large cost of health insurance for those who qualify.

The premium tax credits can be received as a monthly advancement paid directly to the insurance company to offset the premiums paid out of pocket, or they can be received by filing Form 8962 at tax time and claiming the credit directly on the taxpayer’s tax return.

Those who choose to receive monthly advancements will have to estimate their income for the year to determine how much of a credit they are eligible to receive and will still be required to file Form 8962 with their tax return to reconcile the amount of payments received with the amount of payments that should have been received based on actual income at year end.

Given the significant benefit of premium tax credits, it is important for individuals who plan to retire early to consider whether they will qualify for premium tax credits and which planning strategies are available to enhance the benefits they can receive.

Key Takeaway:

Premium tax credits can substantially reduce the cost of health insurance purchased through the Health Insurance Marketplace.

Strategies to Maximize Premium Tax Credits:

Individuals who are retiring early and want to maximize premium tax credits can do so by planning proactively to manage their income during the initial years of retirement.

While any strategy that reduces modified adjusted gross income can be helpful such as contributing to HSA accounts, maximizing pre-tax retirement accounts (i.e. IRA and employer account contributions if eligible), tax loss harvesting, etc., individuals who begin planning a few years ahead of retirement will have more flexibility to qualify for credits once they retire.

For example, one option is to begin building up cash balances or a standard brokerage account during the final working years. This provides a source of funds that can be used to cover living expenses in the initial years of retirement with minimal tax consequences for withdrawals.

By pulling out contributions on a tax-free basis, modified adjusted gross income on the tax return remains low, allowing for higher premium tax credits.

For example, let’s assume John and Jill from our example above need $100,000 of annual cash flow each year from age 61 through age 64. To create this cash flow, they could build up a standard brokerage account or cash account to $400,000 to bridge the gap between when they retire until they go on Medicare. By doing so, they could achieve the annual cash flow they desire with only a minimal amount of interest, dividend, and/or capital gain income.

If John and Jill were to implement a strategy like this using a cash account instead of a standard brokerage account, it would be important that they make sure their cash balances are still working for them versus sitting in a low-yield checking account.

To do this, they could hold their cash balances in a cash solution such as Flourish Cash which would allow them to earn a competitive interest rate on these balances, maintain FDIC insurance coverage on the full $400,000 balance, and still maintain the ability to access their cash whenever they need it.

Building up a standard taxable or cash account may be a good way to provide income in retirement without creating a significant amount of taxable income, but some individuals may not have enough time to build up these balances to bridge the gap between when they retire and enroll in Medicare. If this is the case, another strategy may be to use a Roth IRA to provide for cash flow needs and bridge this gap.

For individuals who have gradually built up a Roth IRA over the years, accessing some of the funds early in retirement may make sense to keep income low. Qualified distributions from Roth IRAs are completely tax free which creates the desired cash flow without increasing modified adjusted gross income.

For individuals who have very little or no balance in a Roth IRA, this may not seem like a good option, especially given the annual contribution limit for a Roth IRA is only $7,000 (or $8,000 for individuals over the age of 50) for 2025.

However, one way to quickly build up a Roth IRA balance is through Roth conversions. A Roth conversion transfers investments from a Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. The conversion is a taxable event, but once in the Roth IRA, all future growth is completely tax free, and all qualified distributions are also tax free.

To show how a Roth conversion strategy might work, we can continue to use John and Jill from our previous examples, but now let’s assume they are three years away from retirement. They still want $100,000 in annual cash flow, but they only have $100,000 in cash and don’t have the cash flow to build this balance up to $400,000 by the time they retire.

They currently have $2,000,000 in retirement accounts, broken out between $1,900,000 in Traditional IRAs and $100,000 in Roth IRAs. So, the combination of their Roth IRAs and cash balances wouldn’t be enough to bridge the four year gap from their retirement at age 61 until they would enroll in Medicare at age 65.

However, they could facilitate Roth conversions of $100,000 each year over the next three years to build up their Roth IRA accounts. Assuming they will be in a combined marginal tax bracket of 26% (24% Federal + 2% State) over those same three years, they would pay taxes of $26,000 each year ($78,000 total) on the conversions.

By using their cash balances to pay the tax on the conversions, the end result would leave them with $400,000 in their Roth IRAs and $22,000 in cash as shown in the chart below.

Example graph roth conversion to lower taxable income

This would then allow them to use the balances in their Roth IRAs to provide the cash flow they need over the first four years of retirement while still keeping their taxable income very low in order to qualify for premium tax credits.

When considering a Roth IRA strategy as described above, it is important to ensure compliance with the two separate 5-year rules for qualified withdrawals from Roth IRAs. For individuals who have had their Roth IRAs for over five years and are over age 59 ½ when they start making withdrawals, the 5-year rules are unlikely to be problematic.

Individuals who are interested in a Roth conversion strategy to create opportunities for lower income in the initial years of retirement need to engage in proactive tax planning to understand their current marginal tax rate and the cost of converting compared to future costs.

For an individual who is in a high tax bracket during their final working years, the cost of a conversion may be significantly higher than what they would pay during retirement which could offset a large portion of premium tax credit savings; so proper planning is critical.

Ultimately, the key point is that premium tax credits can cover a significant portion of health insurance costs for early retirees, and the amount of premium tax credits can be maximized with proactive planning based on your family’s unique circumstances.

Key Takeaway:

Proactive planning can significantly increase the premium tax credits received by early retirees and reduce their out-of-pocket premium costs in the years prior to enrolling in Medicare.

Conclusion:

Health insurance is often one of the largest concerns individuals have as they consider retirement, especially for those retiring before age 65. For these individuals, health insurance often comes in the form of COBRA continuation coverage or by shopping for a plan through the Health Insurance Marketplace.

In either case, it is important to find a plan that fits your specific needs by understanding what is and isn’t covered by the plan, what you are responsible to pay, and if the plan’s network includes your preferred doctors and healthcare providers.

Additionally, with the high cost of health insurance, proper planning to maximize premium tax credits is important for those who would like to offset the cost of health insurance as they enter early retirement.

If you are considering early retirement and would like to begin planning for the most effective way to mitigate and cover the costs of health insurance, one of our Family CFOs would love to connect to see if what we do is right for you.

About Prairiewood Wealth Management:

We are a fiduciary, fee-only, independent wealth management firm that is committed to providing full-service investment management and financial planning to our clients. We include one of our in-house CPAs in the ongoing planning process and utilize our professional network of estate and insurance professionals to integrate detailed tax, estate, insurance, and charitable giving planning into the full wealth management process. We are committed to generational service so that we can be the last wealth management firm our clients will ever need.

More:

Our clients are individuals and families who need comprehensive wealth management services, whose largest lifetime expense is taxes, and who value having an advisor who can plan and coordinate all areas of their financial life. We are dedicated to helping each of our clients keep more of what they make, make more with what they have, and create a legacy that will last beyond their lifetimes.

As an SEC-registered investment advisory firm located in Fargo, ND, we work with clients regardless of location using virtual meetings or are happy to meet in-person with clients from the local area. If you are interested in learning more about our firm or would like a free consultation to see if what we do is right for you, please feel free to reach out to us at service@pw-wm.com or visit our website at pw-wm.com.

Keep Reading